I speak about the making of 'Gi', my short film, SRFTI, its culture of sexual harassment and challenges that one faces as a woman in a film school.
Godard famously said 'Every edit is a lie'. I totally agree. Every cut is a lie. Every shot is stolen. All stories are told. I am a nasty thief. This is a film student's diary.
Tuesday, 28 November 2017
Sunday, 12 November 2017
New Clothes are Definitely Coming. After Ten Years | Shrink Tales
I went to therapy thinking of my lethargy. Once a month
comes a period of time when i know that i have a ton to do and yet all i want
to and can do is sleep. Ish, my therapist, told me that i didn’t have to worry
about that. Even though i didn’t have a job, there was something in my mind
that told me that it was okay and that there would be a plan, eventually. It
was true. There were thoughts lurking in the back of my mind regarding my
career. No, not career, just ways of making money.
When i told Ish that i had not started taking the medicines
according to the new dosage prescribed by my psychiatrist, she tried her best
to look angry and gave it to me. Yeah, now i will have to call the psychiatrist
and get scolded by her too, probably, and start taking the new dosage but i
felt that it was worth it when i saw Ish trying to put on an angry face. She
told me that i was to message her after i spoke to the psychiatrist. She was ‘holding
me accountable,’ she said. Like a lot of things, it sounded like a nice thing
when she said it. Had it been Mother, i would probably have thrown a tantrum
saying it was violation of my privacy or something such.
[No, i did not call the psychiatrist. Started taking the new dosage.]
When i told her about Director of SRFTI, Debamitra Mitra’s letter to
me congratulating me for the IFFI selection, she asked me if she (Debamitra)
would have got what i meant through my reply. ‘No,’ i said, ‘because she is
stupid.’
I just can’t stand that woman. Maybe i should write a postcard to her.
Later that week i did write to her again, when they sent the
wrong disc for screening at Goa. It was not about what i wrote. I just wanted
to let her know that i hated her, i guess. Here is the letter anyway. Even
though she is a woman, i felt like humiliating her when i wrote that letter. In
front of the Goa festival authorities – because everyone says it’s a big deal –
like how she and many others had humiliated me. Below iss my letter.
This is outrageous.Dear SRFTI,First you make public my name, now everyone from my school, college etc can identify me as a 'rape victim' and now on top of that is this.Please send the DCP. Copying HoD and Director, SRFTI to make a note of this. Also Vaibhav Hiwase, who faced a similar situation earlier. ICC Chairperson because of the nature of what you did.Thanks!
I wanted to scare her too,
because that was all i had. But now after some days of writing the letter, and
while writing it here for Ish to read, i kind of feel bad for her. I feel bad
that i consider her stupid. Also that she is in love with or living with a
complete abuser.
I hope what LJ once told me about Jay (ex-lover) is true. When Ga told
me that she was seeing Jay, i asked her to be careful. Extremely cautious about
getting physical with him. When i told this to LJ, she got angry with me and
asked me why i had said that. I told her that i was warning her, because of how
Jay was with me. Then she said something that stuck in my head like how some of
Ish’s statements do. She asked me how i knew that Jay would be abusive with
everyone. He could be in love with Ga, they could be having a really good time.
If it had been a mallu film, one could have easily added a bleaching of the
screen to indicate an epiphany over there. LJ probably thought it was just
sexual jealousy and not concern for Ga that made me say that. I no longer
remember what it was. But yes, that was when i even started thinking of people
who had hurt me having a completely normal life, being absolutely loving and
caring to other people.
Speaking of sexual jealousy, my partner and i again had
talks. It kind of half-broke my heart. Whenever i talk to him about the
problems in my sex life, i feel that he is a baby and that i am the only person
who will pick him up when he is crying. Like a neglected child. I want to hold
him close and smother him in an attempt to take all the sadness away. Yet,
holding his cold hands, i spoke to him about us going to a doctor.
His hands become cold whenever i talk about it. It happens
when he is scared.
I think problems in a woman's sex life, an abused woman's sex life have to be seen in the light of the social setting of the place. For most men, before they meet their first lover/wife etc. their biggest fear is if they will be able to 'perform'. It's after becoming physically intimate with respective partners that they are assuaged. Now if a woman one day tells this man, she is having problems in her sex life and she would like him to help her, the notion of maleness created by the society will make him doubt himself. That's the curse of patriarchy. It's shitty and useless.
I think problems in a woman's sex life, an abused woman's sex life have to be seen in the light of the social setting of the place. For most men, before they meet their first lover/wife etc. their biggest fear is if they will be able to 'perform'. It's after becoming physically intimate with respective partners that they are assuaged. Now if a woman one day tells this man, she is having problems in her sex life and she would like him to help her, the notion of maleness created by the society will make him doubt himself. That's the curse of patriarchy. It's shitty and useless.
And the woman, especially if it is one like me, waiting to feel guilty, will take it upon herself. She will feel guilty of having made the partner feel bad. I remembered how my partner had returned home upset one night after i had had the talk. Even when i asked repeatedly that day, he had just said that he had just felt like
seeing his mother.
In my paranoid mind the thought of going back to his mother probably rose from it being that one space where he wouldn’t be judged by his ‘manhood’. Rather that was the space where ‘manhood’ was to be removed at the entrance, like footwear, before entering.
In my paranoid mind the thought of going back to his mother probably rose from it being that one space where he wouldn’t be judged by his ‘manhood’. Rather that was the space where ‘manhood’ was to be removed at the entrance, like footwear, before entering.
My partner asked me if my therapist had asked me to leave him if he didn't agree with us going to a doctor. I said no and buried him in my bosom, as much
as i could. I then repeated the thing that brought tears to my eyes at the
session.
Ish had said that it showed that i loved him a lot because
even when i feared that he would leave me once we went to a doctor, i wanted us to do it. For all the selfishness i
have, i couldn’t bring myself to hide it from him that there was a solution or
a possibility. True that i would also feel great if i could have a better sex
life (i still don’t want to believe this). It could be selfish.
Not having a job is eating my brain in just small ways, i
guess. Like i got angry thinking that i always bought Vai Vow clothes when i
felt he needed some and even though he had started earning so much, he was not
even thinking of buying me anything before going to Goa. Of course i am still
waiting for him to figure it out himself. So i expect to get some new clothes
from him after ten years. Men!
When i pulled out a red pen to scribble something, i thought
of the exercise that my earlier psychologist, Ms. Mullick had asked me to do.
Scribble on pages with red ink pen when i felt like harming myself. I could
also clench ice in my fist or take a cold shower. When Mother heard this, she
bought me a red pen. I felt really bad thinking of Mother. She was always
buying me things to get me out of my problems, i felt. Even when she gave me
money to make films, she probably just saw it as a means in which her girl
would be less sad.
I named her as the person who would come with me to Goa with
free tickets.
Vai Vow made fun of me saying that no one went to Goa
with parents. That’s okay, she is not parents. She is Mother. She bought me
pens.
Thought for therapy today, will my partner be okay?
Sunday, 5 November 2017
Job's Gone, Want to Sleep, Want to Give Up | Shrink Tales
So my job's gone. The company is shutting down. I just have a couple of weeks left to find another job, if i want to find another job, that is. I say 'if' because my new tantrum is lethargy. I just don't want to do any work. I just want to sleep all the time. Thoughts of SRFTI - the film school that has a great role in my mental health problems - keep coming to me and make me sad.
My film 'Gi' got selected in International Film Festival of India [IFFI], Goa. I have been told that it is a big deal. I didn't know it was. Now with this achievement, people who had harmed and hurt me for no reason, started speaking with me. Tagging me on Facebook, accepting congratulations, i still don't understand what is so great about this.
On top of that, the Director of SRFTI, that woman who lives with Shyamal Sengupta, a professor who sexually harassed me and many more women, and who drove me to suicide the last time i went to SRFTI, sent me a letter congratulating me.
I am extremely elated to learn that your film has been selected for this year's IFFI. Like any head of an institution, I feel immensely proud for your achievement. This feat, so early in your career, speaks volumes about your talent and ingenuity.This was her message. I couldn't believe it. I always try to be nice towards women but this was just beyond me and i wrote this scathing reply.
I wish you a great and successful career ahead.
Blessings,
Dear Debamitra,
I am extremely intrigued by the level of your shamelessness. Like any woman who has been subjected to sexual harassment and wronged by the system, I feel immensely sorry for you. This vengeance, even while being a woman who is much older than me speaks volumes about your inherent patriarchy and insensitivity.
I hope you apologise to every woman whom you have failed in SRFTI, including me.
Intrigued,
kunjila
People who had attacked me and other fighter women are now seen 'liking' posts on Facebook regarding the achievement. I always say 'we' and 'our' while talking about the films i direct but with this film i have always been careful to say 'my'. It is just my hard work because everyone within and outside the crew was just trying to push me against the wall and make my job so so difficult. Assholes, all of them!
I spoke to my partner about the problems in our sex life. May be we will go to a doctor one day. But it was news to me when during therapy, Ish explained how men lost their virginity by masturbation and it never really mattered just because they were men. She told me that male foreskin going back would be painful to most men.
Regarding problems that arose out of being abused as a child, she said that it usually resulted in erectile dysfunction, ejaculating soon etc. for men. Hey have you ever had this experience where you bring up abuse with a male and they tell you a story of how they were abused as a child? Just thought of that. Because science just told me it results in different problems.
You know what, while i want to have a better sex life, i also am scared that my loving relationship with my partner will change and become violent as soon as it happens. Because i have always felt that the act of penetration itself is violent and it is impossible to do it without being at least a little violent towards your female partner's body. I fear that this will change everything and the one relationship where i am not being abused will turn into abuse.
Maybe i should stop thinking about sex. I don't see this going anywhere. I mean, we ended on a note where i said jokingly that my partner would soon find someone else when we fixed our problem. She said that we would have to talk about that notion. Of course, it springs from my low self esteem and needed attention but i am in some zone where nothing really matters. I just want to sleep.
Ish asked me why i was scared of hurting my partner by talking about sex. I consider him fragile. I remember the time when i had mailed Han about having feelings for him. My partner had read it and was weeping when i came back to the room. Oh! I would never ever want him to be in such a position. I reprimanded myself so much for that seeing how hurt he was.
I feel he is precious. Too precious that he had to be kept away from me because i have violence within me. I could hurt him.
Scared of a Relapse, Sex Talks Continue | Shrink Tales
I was anxious when i left for therapy. I was not sure of
what had happened the previous week, with me bunking office and cancelling
train tickets. I was scared it was a relapse and that Ish, my therapist would confirm my
fear.
When i read the aftermath [what Ish calls these writings], Ish told me that i had got the
postcard idea wrong. It was not necessary that the postcard had to be to people
whom i hated. [I had failed to come up with results for this definition.] It
could be people i was angry with or people who hurt me a lot. That was easy, i
thought. I was to do it on the Saturday before the therapy Sunday.
It was a relief when she said that my sleeping and
cancelling plans and not working were not signs of relapse, but of a sense of
relief. When i had gone to the psychiatrist, she had reduced the dosage of one
of my pills – Lithium. When she gave me the feeling that i had gained weight,
it didn’t not affect me as much as it usually does. These were positive signs
and proof that i was improving. May be my mind wanted to relish those moments
by not doing anything.
Sex still continues to be a problem. When i think of it i
think of a tortoise. I feel that it is a part of me that cannot be penetrated –
[the choice of word is intentional because i am a genius. No, it was
accidental.] There is a difference in the way that therapy has become ever
since i started discussing this problem of mine. As always, i shall try to
express the feeling in words so that i get more clarity myself.
Up until now, whenever Ish told me what she thought of what
i thought, i had been able to distance myself from myself and think of it and
see that it was true. Even her suggestions like asking me to try to talk to Mother about her – gave me hope. Here, however, like a tortoise, i felt that i
had this thick shell on me that even Ish would not be able to crack. It was
something only LJ could crack, i felt. But then again, LJ too was a victim
and an asexual being. So speaking to her about sex would just make me feel even
worse. I mean my life’s goal is to be asexual like her.
The problem is that i don’t think the way i feel about sex
is something that came to me naturally. Like me being sexually attracted to
women – it came naturally and it was not introduced to me by anyone. But penile
penetration was ‘introduced’ [read rape] though violence. It was common that
through such experiences of violence you started to get pleasure out of the act
itself.
Me thinking that my partner only wanted my body, constantly
checking what he would do if i didn’t have sex with him. Perhaps it was related
to LJ. She, when she said that her husband loved her, also spoke about how he
waited for her at night, a man who is used to sleeping early. About how much he
loved her even though they had sex maybe just once a year. Yes, in previous
therapy sessions i had realized that there was no point in seeking a perfect kind
of love but still i yearn for that, i feel.
Ish told me about
trust. Like a litmus test, i used sex as a test where i would be able to tell
if the man is right for me or not. Where i was most vulnerable. This made a lot of sense to me. It really looked as if i used sex for the said purpose. May be this was why LJ once hurt me so much by telling me that i slept with people at the drop of a hat.
I liked it when Ish said that she took care to constantly
remind me that i was doing good. I realized how that had actually helped me. I
would come back home and squeak to my partner that Ish had said that i was
making progress. To see the smile on his face. I wish Mother was able to see me
too, going through this process of healing. She would also then be able to
understand, looking at me, that healing is possible. I know! I should tell her
whenever i see that she is making progress! Wow! Why didn’t i think of this
earlier!
Han asked me something: Why don’t you ask for things? Why
don’t you ever ask for help? With luggage, internet, everything – i don’t know
when this started.
Me getting startled when people call me, touch has always
been a problem – but when a co-worker always answers to your call with a start,
it looks awkward. It just struck me because i am interacting with more people
and so more occasions of them calling me are arising. I do have one memory of this
happening in degree and how Athulya had said that i was making it up.
Good thing – resumed reading.
I have started seeing Mother everywhere. Like on the road, i would think that Mother was walking when i saw someone with hair plaited, wearing salwar kameez.
I am having a great time talking to Mother now. But i
realised that she is a broken human being. May be more than me.
She wants to do
things to people who abused me. It is not
just about them having done things to me. It is that she holds them
responsible for ruining the family life she and her husband had envisaged for
us. It might be her way of running away from taking responsibility, something i
do too, by blaming these men. She wouldn’t blame her husband whom she loved and
lost. It was better channelizing her anger to these men who in any case
deserved to be punished.
I told her how i had, through therapy, gotten over
abuse. How i look at those periods differently now. I didn’t want to hang the
abusers or ruin their lives. It was the victim’s prerogative after all. Mother
didn’t seem convinced. She has, in the past created ruckus in places in
public where she had spotted some of these men. It was highly probable, with
Mallu land being an even smaller world than the already small world.
How can she be healed, i thought. And i felt that it was up
to me.
However easy i thought it would be for me to draw a picture
postcard to person or people who hurt me, i drew a blank on Saturday when i sat
in front of the book. I drew a copy of a photo from long ago, in which Mother
and baby me were there. She was carrying me on her shoulder and looking at me
with so much love in her eyes that the whole photo was about that love. I just
wrote ‘aren’t we both awesome’ in the message part.
Did i just realize that i have nothing to say to those
people who hurt me? I’ll find out soon, i guess.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
-
At a great phase of life. A steady source of income. Closer to cinema than ever. In a strange land where I know no one and no one know...
-
When i was going to make a music video during my graduation days i used to watch the song made by Avial band for the film Sancharram. I ...
-
Peruvazhiyambalam - P Padmarajan By Source, Fair use, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?curid=32000911 Padmarajan's debut as...